Forget bland burritos and frozen margaritas! Columbia, South Carolina harbors a hidden treasure waiting to be discovered: a vibrant and diverse Mexican food scene that will excite your palate and transport you south of the border. The days of searching for “Midland-only” culinary experiences are over. Here in Columbia, you’ll encounter a delightful array of eateries, from charming, family-operated taquerias nestled on side streets to sophisticated establishments offering modern interpretations of classic Mexican dishes.
Whether you’re a connoisseur of authentic Oaxacan mole or a casual fan craving perfectly seasoned carne asada, Columbia’s Mexican restaurants cater to every desire. This city embraces the rich tapestry of Mexican cuisine, offering everything from street-style tacos brimming with fresh ingredients to meticulously crafted plates showcasing unique regional specialties. Don’t be surprised to find yourself savoring a hand-crafted margarita infused with fresh fruit flavors or indulging in a towering stack of fluffy churros drizzled with warm chocolate sauce – Columbia’s Mexican eateries are committed to providing a genuine taste of Mexico in a lively and inviting atmosphere.
Local favorites have earned their well-deserved reputation among both residents and visitors. These restaurants are renowned for their dedication to using fresh, high-quality ingredients and creating unique recipes that honor Mexico’s rich culinary heritage. Whether you’re a college student seeking an affordable taco stand for a quick and delicious lunch or a couple looking for a romantic evening with upscale ambiance and innovative dishes, Columbia’s Mexican scene offers something for everyone.
This blog post serves as your definitive guide to the Top 10 Mexican Restaurants in Columbia, SC (2024). We’ll explore the must-try spots, from hidden gems favored by locals to established restaurants known for their consistent quality. From budget-friendly taquerias perfect for a casual weeknight dinner to upscale establishments offering a taste of modern Mexican cuisine, this list has you covered. So, bring your appetite and prepare to embark on a delicious culinary journey through the heart of Columbia!
Yearning for a taste of Jalisco with an emphasis on tequila and fresh seafood? El Jimador Restaurante is your destination. This local gem in Northeast Columbia distinguishes itself with a unique fusion of classic Mexican dishes and fresh, coastal flavors.
Indulge in their signature “Parrillada Jalisciense,” a sizzling platter featuring grilled meats such as carne asada (skirt steak) and chorizo sausage, ideal for group sharing. For a maritime flavor, their “Camarones a la Diabla” (shrimp “a la devil”) presents succulent shrimp immersed in a spicy chipotle sauce, guaranteed to excite your palate.
El Jimador’s true treasure, however, is its spacious patio. Verdant foliage and comfortable seating create a tranquil oasis, perfect for savoring a hand-crafted margarita (they offer over 100 tequilas!) with friends while the tantalizing aroma of grilled cuisine permeates the air.
According to Columbia residents, El Jimador’s blend of distinctive dishes, tequila focus, and serene patio experience establishes it as a top choice for a memorable Mexican dining adventure.
Taquito
Poblano Soup
Fajito Pablano
Looking for a familiar taste of Mexico with an emphasis on value and diverse options? San Jose Mexican Restaurant is a Columbia staple renowned for its generous servings and inviting atmosphere. This family-friendly chain offers all the classic Mexican dishes you desire, prepared with fresh ingredients and a focus on affordability.
Their signature “Fajitas for Two” presents a sizzling array of marinated meats with all the accompaniments, ideal for sharing (or tackling solo!). For a lighter option, their soft “Alambre” tacos, featuring steak or chicken with bell peppers and onions, provide a flavorful and satisfying choice.
San Jose’s true strength lies in its spacious patios, a common feature across their various Columbia locations. Adorned with string lights and comfortable seating, these outdoor spaces create a relaxed ambiance, perfect for savoring a margarita with friends or enjoying a family dinner beneath the South Carolina sky.
According to Columbia residents, San Jose’s combination of familiar favorites, budget-friendly options, and reliable patio dining establishes it as a top choice for a satisfying and casual Mexican dining experience.
Carne Asado
Fajita Nachos
Chalupo
Yearning for a taste of Mexico with a contemporary flair and a vibrant patio scene? Look no further than Cantina 76! This lively establishment in the heart of Columbia transcends the typical taco joint. They present a modern interpretation of classic Mexican dishes, utilizing fresh, seasonal ingredients to craft innovative flavor combinations.
Indulge in their signature “Carnitas Street Tacos” featuring crispy pork shoulder and zesty pineapple salsa, or explore their unique “Lobster Enchiladas,” an opulent twist on a traditional favorite. However, Cantina 76’s appeal extends beyond its culinary offerings.
Their spacious, multi-level patio stands as the crown jewel, pulsating with energy and offering captivating city vistas. Twinkling string lights overhead create a festive ambiance, ideal for savoring a handcrafted margarita with friends while the tantalizing aroma of sizzling fajitas permeates the air.
According to Columbia residents, Cantina 76’s blend of innovative cuisine, dynamic atmosphere, and stunning patio experience establishes it as a top choice for a memorable and upscale Mexican dining adventure.
House Nachos
Jalepeno Coleslaw
Watermelon Salsa
Yearning for vibrant flavors and a taste of Mexico City’s street cuisine? Look no further than Masa Mexican Street Food! This local favorite transcends the typical taco joint, offering a genuine culinary adventure. Masa employs fresh, premium ingredients to craft dishes brimming with authenticity.
Indulge in their signature “al pastor” tacos, featuring marinated pork cooked on a trompo (rotating vertical rotisserie) for an explosion of succulent, smoky flavor. Don’t overlook their “guisado” selection, where slow-cooked stews like rich mole or savory barbacoa provide a comforting taste of Mexican tradition.
However, Masa isn’t solely about the food – their lively patio scene is unparalleled. Twinkling string lights create a warm ambiance, perfect for savoring a margarita with friends while the tantalizing aroma of grilling meats permeates the air.
According to Columbia residents, Masa’s combination of authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and a vibrant patio experience establishes it as the unrivaled champion of casual Mexican dining in the city.
Al Pastor
Nopales
Pollo Asado
Molote
Longing for a taste of Mexico with ample servings and amiable service? El Charro Mexican Restaurant in Irmo is a local favorite renowned for its warm hospitality and flavorful cuisine. El Charro presents all the beloved classics, but their emphasis on fresh ingredients enhances the dining experience.
Their “Burrito Gordo,” an enormous flour tortilla filled with your preferred protein, beans, rice, and an array of toppings, is a surefire crowd-pleaser. For a more modest option, sample their “Fajitas,” featuring sizzling marinated meats served atop a bed of onions and peppers, perfect for creating a personalized meal.
El Charro’s true treasure, however, is their expansive patio. Adorned with string lights and comfortable seating, it creates a laid-back ambiance ideal for savoring a margarita with friends or enjoying a family dinner beneath the South Carolina sky.
According to Irmo residents, El Charro’s blend of familiar favorites, generous portions, and an inviting patio experience establishes it as a premier choice for casual Mexican dining.
Fajita
Burrito gordo
Arroz Con Pollo
In search of Mexican flavors in a laid-back, family-oriented setting? La Cienega Mexican Grill & Seafood fits the bill perfectly. This West Columbia treasure offers more than typical Tex-Mex fare, presenting a menu that showcases the diverse tastes of Mexican cuisine.
Their signature “Chile Verde,” a tender pork dish simmered with tomatillos, is a local favorite, exuding fresh, tangy notes. For those desiring a heartier option, the “Enchilada Super Ranchera” combines cheese-filled tortillas with savory ranchero sauce and your preferred protein, promising satisfaction.
Yet La Cienega’s appeal extends beyond its culinary offerings. Their spacious patio provides a relaxed ambiance, ideal for enjoying an unhurried meal with family or friends. Whether basking in the afternoon sunlight or relishing the cool evening air, La Cienega’s outdoor seating allows patrons to savor delectable Mexican flavors in a comfortable, inviting atmosphere.
West Columbia residents assert that La Cienega’s blend of authentic dishes, family-friendly environment, and delightful patio experience positions it as a leading choice for casual Mexican dining.
Tostadas
Texan Fideo
Quesadilla
Chalupa
Discerning diners seeking an upscale Mexican experience in Columbia should look no further than Coa Agaveria y Cocina. This restaurant transcends typical Tex-Mex fare, instead focusing on high-quality ingredients and showcasing the true diversity of Mexican cuisine. Reviewers rave about the delicious, shareable plates, perfect for a fun night out with friends or a romantic date. Coa Agaveria’s emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients and unique flavors ensures an unforgettable culinary adventure. Are you craving an authentic and upscale taste of Mexico? Make a reservation at Coa Agaveria y Cocina and prepare to be impressed!
Elote
Tacos
Mole
Churros
Craving authentic Mexican flavors in a lively, family-oriented setting? Look no further than Taqueria Jalisco! This unassuming eatery on Garnerville Road is a hidden treasure for those seeking genuine Mexican cuisine.
Their menu showcases a variety of tacos, featuring fillings like barbacoa (tender braised beef) and carnitas (succulent slow-cooked pork) that burst with rich, authentic flavors. Venture beyond tacos to explore their “tortas ahogadas,” a unique dish consisting of a toasted bread roll immersed in savory tomato sauce—a must-try for adventurous diners.
Taqueria Jalisco’s appeal extends beyond its culinary offerings. Their vibrant patio is a local favorite, pulsating with energy and offering a glimpse into Mexican street food culture. The colorful décor and amiable staff create an inviting ambiance, ideal for savoring a refreshing agua fresca (fruit drink) with family or friends while the aroma of sizzling meats permeates the air.
Columbia residents assert that Taqueria Jalisco’s combination of authentic cuisine, vibrant atmosphere, and delightful patio experience positions it as a top choice for a casual and flavorful Mexican dining adventure.
Tortilla Soup
Taco Salad
Huevos Rancheros
Searching for an unpretentious taste of authentic Mexico with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and family recipes? Look no further than Real Mexico Restaurant. This hidden treasure on Rosewood Drive is a favorite among locals seeking a departure from the ordinary.
Their menu showcases dishes prepared with simple, genuine ingredients, allowing the true essence of Mexican cuisine to take center stage. Don’t overlook their signature “Mole Poblano,” a rich and intricate sauce simmered with chiles, spices, and chocolate, traditionally accompanying chicken or pork. For a lighter option, their “Carnitas,” tender slow-cooked pork shoulder served with fresh tortillas and a simple salsa, exemplifies the power of quality ingredients.
Real Mexico’s true gem, however, is its charming patio. Furnished with picnic tables and exuding a relaxed ambiance, it evokes the feeling of stepping into a family-run taqueria south of the border. This casual setting, coupled with the focus on authentic flavors, establishes Real Mexico as a top choice for Columbia residents seeking a genuine and delectable Mexican dining experience, according to local enthusiasts.
Huevos Rancheros
Chicken Soup
Loco Burrito
Veggie Fajitas
Immerse yourself in the lively ambiance of Nayarit, Mexico at Tacos Nayarit! This authentic gem on Percival Road presents a taste of regional specialties alongside beloved Mexican classics. Their dedication to fresh, premium ingredients is evident in dishes like their signature “Adobo-Style” meats.
These slow-cooked meats, bathed in a rich, flavorful sauce, boast tender textures and complex spices. For those seeking a vegetarian option, their “Veggie Burrito” offers a vibrant medley of colorful ingredients, proving that plant-based dishes can be equally exciting.
The true highlight of Tacos Nayarit, however, is its inviting patio. With warm hospitality and a relaxed atmosphere, it’s an ideal spot to bask in the sunshine or enjoy a pleasant evening beneath twinkling string lights.
Local patrons praise Tacos Nayarit’s blend of authentic flavors, commitment to quality, and delightful patio experience, positioning it as a top choice for a truly delicious and immersive Mexican dining adventure.
Tacos Quesabirria
Churro
Quesadilla
